Big Five vs personality types explained

The Big Five reports five trait dimensions. A four-letter type code sorts preferences into a category. Those results are not interchangeable.

By Charles · Published · Updated

A teal circle, a sage triangle and a navy square sit above five small dots.

The Big Five describes personality as five broad dimensions, with a score somewhere along each one. A four-letter personality type sorts answers into a category. A score from one system is not a result from the other, even when a word such as extraversion appears in both.

Our guide to how accurate personality tests are explains why evidence for one instrument does not establish the accuracy of another. Take the PersonalityPro test if you want a reflection prompt. It is not a Big Five inventory and it is not the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) assessment.

Key facts

  • The APA Dictionary of Psychology describes the Big Five as a model of primary personality dimensions, usually labeled extraversion, neuroticism, agreeableness, conscientiousness, and openness to experience. It says the labels vary among researchers. Updated 19 April 2018.
  • The same dictionary treats the five-factor personality model as a related but distinct claim: the Big Five describes behavior and a taxonomy of differences, while the five-factor model treats the factors as psychological entities with causal force. Updated 19 April 2018.
  • The Myers & Briggs Foundation says the MBTI framework combines four preference pairs into 16 type codes, and that the assessment sorts for preferences rather than measuring traits. Accessed 10 November 2026.
  • PersonalityPro's terms say the product is for self-reflection and entertainment and is not a psychological assessment.

What does a Big Five result report?

It reports where someone stands on broad trait dimensions, not a membership card for one of 16 types.

The APA Dictionary of Psychology describes the Big Five personality model as the primary dimensions of individual differences in personality. The usual labels are extraversion, neuroticism, agreeableness, conscientiousness, and openness to experience, and the dictionary notes that researchers do not all use those exact words. Lewis R. Goldberg and Gerard T. Saucier are among the people it credits with describing the model. APA Dictionary, updated 19 April 2018.

That dictionary also separates the Big Five from the five-factor personality model associated with Robert R. McCrae and Paul T. Costa Jr. In the dictionary's account, the Big Five treats the dimensions as descriptions of behavior and as a taxonomy of differences. The five-factor model treats the factors as psychological entities with causal force. The entry says the two are frequently, and incorrectly, conflated. APA Dictionary, updated 19 April 2018. A page that says "Big Five" and a page that says "five-factor model" are not automatically talking about the same claim.

One public-domain example is the 50-item IPIP sample of Goldberg's Big Five markers. The page asks people to describe themselves as they generally are now, not as they wish to be. Its scoring note names five scales: Extraversion, Agreeableness, Conscientiousness, Emotional Stability, and Intellect/Imagination. Those names are not the APA list. The page attributes the markers to Goldberg's 1992 article in Psychological Assessment. The IPIP page is undated; accessed 10 November 2026. What you get from that questionnaire is a set of scale scores, not a four-letter code.

What does a four-letter type code report?

It reports a category built by picking one side of each preference pair the test uses.

The Myers & Briggs Foundation describes four MBTI preference pairs: Extraversion or Introversion, Sensing or Intuition, Thinking or Feeling, and Judging or Perceiving. Combining one from each pair produces one of 16 type codes. The Foundation says the assessment sorts for preferences and does not measure traits, ability, skill, or character. It also says most people prefer one side of a pair more than the other, while still using all of the preferences. Myers & Briggs Foundation, accessed 10 November 2026. That page is the publisher's account of its own instrument. It is not evidence about every other test that prints a four-letter code.

PersonalityPro uses its own five aspects. Our theory explains that the first four supply the letters and the fifth, Identity, adds an A or T suffix. A shared letter with an MBTI code does not mean the two results are the same.

How do the two reports differ?

Read the format of the result before you compare the words.

QuestionBig Five-style trait profileFour-letter type code
What you receiveA position on each broad dimension the inventory scoresA category built from the test's preference pairs
A concrete exampleThe IPIP marker scales named aboveThe MBTI's 16 codes, or PersonalityPro's own code plus an A or T suffix
What it is notA diagnosis, a job assignment, or a type letterA Big Five scale score, or proof that people fall into discrete groups

The APA dictionary's definition of a personality type is broad: a category people may be classified into on the basis of traits, attitudes, behavior, or other characteristics. A category and a dimension can both be useful descriptions. They are still different kinds of report.

Can you translate a type letter into a Big Five score?

No translation between PersonalityPro and a Big Five inventory was verified for this article. Similar names do not make the scales the same.

The APA dictionary describes extraversion as a broad trait on a continuum. A test that sorts people onto one side of a pair is doing a different job, even when it uses a familiar word. Research or a publisher's statement about one questionnaire applies to that questionnaire. Our accuracy guide is the checklist for asking what a specific score is allowed to mean.

How to use personality test results suggests checking a description against examples from your own life. PersonalityPro's pricing page lists two one-time $9.99 reports, the Career Guide and the Relationship Guide, built from its five scores. They are reflection guides, not Big Five profiles. The terms say PersonalityPro is for self-reflection and entertainment and is not a psychological, medical, career, or relationship assessment.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the Big Five and a personality type?

The Big Five describes five broad dimensions with a score along each one. A personality type assigns a category, such as a four-letter code. They are different reports, and a result on one is not a result on the other.

Is PersonalityPro a Big Five test?

No. PersonalityPro reports its own five aspects and a type code. It is not an IPIP Big Five inventory and not the five-factor model.

Is a PersonalityPro type the same as an MBTI type?

No. The Myers & Briggs Foundation describes the MBTI as its own preference assessment. PersonalityPro uses a separate framework, including an A or T suffix the MBTI type code does not use.

Does a familiar trait name mean two tests measure the same thing?

No. Labels such as extraversion appear in more than one model, and the wording and scoring still belong to the specific test.

For a reflection prompt from this site, take the PersonalityPro test. Read the result as a set of questions to check, not as a Big Five score.